A friend of mine told me about a Magic the Gathering format called
Forgetful Fish. Like commander (which is what I usually play),
it was a format created by the community. Nick Floyd created the format in the winter 1996 centered around the
card "DanDan". The main premise is that players share a library and graveyard. Without the problems of
imbalanced power levels and meta-level counterpicks, this shared-deck feature combined with a bunch of blue
deck-manipulation spells makes for some great battle-of-wits type gameplay. The format was officially shared
more broadly in an
official google doc
but has yet to reach as wide of a sub-community within MTG as I think it deserves.
So on my winter break in 2025, I decided to make an online version with a fully fleshed out game engine to
support it. There are other third-party online TCG clients for games like Riftbound
(riftatlas) but they usually require players to know and respect the
rules as there is not programmatic enforcement of all of the rules. To make this more of a chess.com style
matchmaking site and to support the ability to create AI opponents for people looking to play solo, I decided
to build the actual rules engine for this too.
There are a few open-source MTG rules engines out there like
Forge and
XMage but they were difficult to modify for this shared-deck
structure and lacked implementations for some of the more abnormal (color-modifying) cards that the format made
use of. AI coding agents had recently become actually useful, so with XMage as a reference, Cursor, and
Sonnet 4.5, I created a custom rules engine with the small subset of content I needed to support Forgetful Fish.
There's certainly a few bugs left to deal with and I would like to revisit this project to polish it up and make
a better AI, but I was able to get a fairly desirable result up-and-deployed before the end of break! Please
take a look if the format sounds fun to try and send me a message if you'd like to
play sometime!